Seeking independent opinions on a disputed Android bug-bounty severity assessment
Hi everyone, I’m an independent security researcher looking for an outside perspective on the handling of an Android security vulnerability. The report was accepted, subsequently fixed by the vendor, and rewarded. However, I believe the original Low severity assessment may not have fully reflected the demonstrated security impact. The issue involved a third-party content-delivery prerequisite combined with an application-controlled native WebView trust boundary. The original evidence demonstrated access to privileged application functionality and authenticated own-account capabilities. My proposed CVSS v3.1 assessment was 7.1 (High), while the vendor classified the issue as Low, placing significant weight on the local-app prerequisite and third-party dependency. I recognize that CVSS severity and bug-bounty reward decisions are not necessarily identical. I also acknowledge that I accepted the original payment and withdrew an earlier request to reconsider its amount. I am not claiming that an agreed payment remains outstanding. I’m now seeking an independent technical and procedural review. I’d appreciate community opinions on three questions: How should a vendor-controlled trust boundary be evaluated when the initial content-delivery condition belongs to a third-party integration? Is a Low classification necessarily appropriate where exploitation requires a co-installed application but authenticated-session impact has been demonstrated? Is it reasonable to request a post-payment independent severity review and potential discretionary supplemental reward? I am withholding exploit details and private disclosure materials while confirming the applicable disclosure restrictions. I would appreciate technical reasoning and experience with similar bug-bounty triage situations. Thank you 1 post - 1 participant Read full topic
Get stories like this every Monday
The week's most important AI news in one email. Free, unsubscribe anytime.
Score: 2.27
Engagement proxy: 0
Canonical link: https://community.disclose.io/t/seeking-independent-opinions-on-a-disputed-android-bug-bounty-severity-assessment/1113